| 9.8°C Dublin

€40k for holidaymaker who lost tip of finger after catching it on sunbed


Vincent Reid

Vincent Reid

Vincent Reid

A HOLIDAYMAKER has been awarded €40,000 after he lost the tip of one of his fingers due to a defective catching mechanism on a sunbed at his hotel swimming pool.

Vincent Reid (72), a retired construction manager from Lisburn, Co Antrim, sued Topflight Ltd, the travel agency which provided the week-long package holiday for him and his wife to the Hotel Savoy Palace, Lake Garda, Italy, in August 2012.

Topflight, which was sued as organiser of the holiday under the 1995 Package Holidays and Travel Trade Act, has issued proceedings in Italy for an indemnity against the hotel as provider of the sunbed service, the High Court heard.

Topflight claimed the accident was not forseeable.


The sun lounger involved worked on the basis of armrests on either side catching in place before a person leans back on it.

Mr Reid had sat down to read a paper on the fourth day of his holiday, on August 29, when the sunbed almost immediately collapsed and blood poured from his right middle finger.

Mr Justice Michael Hanna believed the accident was "eminently foreseeable" and the defendant was liable for the negligence claim under the 1995 Act.

The fact that the lounger was liable to collapse if catching mechanisms on both arm rests were not fully engaged must have been known to staff, he said.

He was satisfied the accident involving Mr Reid was not the first time such a collapse had happened.

The court was also told that a similar accident had occurred a couple of days earlier to another guest, an Irishwoman, at the same hotel.

Mr Reid was treated at a local hospital but his finger was in a splint for around 12 weeks afterwards.

Mr Justice Hanna was satisfied he had ongoing pain with reduced movement in his finger and affecting day to day activities like gardening and DIY.

He awarded him €40,796.